Case Summaries · Retail
Hunkemöller: Cheyne, Man Group, Contrarian and Redwood go to war over lingerie
Redwood Capital Management took control of the €272.5m notes Hunkemöller issued in 2022, amended the indenture to let it charge ahead, funded itself with a super senior loan and then enforced, taking the company and what was left of the secured debt for itself.
The three funds left holding €84.3m of stub notes, Cheyne, Contrarian and Man Group vehicles, have taken the same grievance to three courts: New York, Amsterdam and London. The English judgment of 6 August 2026 tells the whole story.
Redwood Capital Management, which held a controlling position in Hunkemöller's notes, amended the indenture, funded itself ahead of the rest of the stack and then enforced, transferring the company's shares and the whole of the secured debt to its own vehicle in March 2025. The funds left behind — Cheyne, Contrarian and Man Group vehicles holding €84.3m of the stub notes, with Cheyne’s special situations and strategic value credit funds leading the litigation — took the same grievance to three courts: New York, Amsterdam and London. What follows is how a €440m private equity bet on lingerie became a war between two groups of distressed investors.
How we got here
Hunkemöller was founded in Amsterdam in 1886 by Wilhelm Hunkemöller and his wife Josephina Lexis as a corsetry shop, and grew over the next century into the market leader in Dutch and Belgian lingerie. The Dutch retail group Maxeda owned it until late 2010, when the French private equity firm PAI Partners agreed to buy it, completing the acquisition in February 2011 — the price undisclosed at announcement, later reported at €260m to €280m, alongside ~€180m of new senior and mezzanine debt.
In December 2015, PAI agreed to sell a controlling interest to The Carlyle Group for a reported ~€440m. Under Carlyle, the store network grew to more than 900 stores across more than twenty countries, and sales rose from around €400m to close to €700m. In September 2021, Carlyle launched a sale process seeking more than €1bn for the business.
In March 2022, Carlyle sold (terms undisclosed) to Dutch investor Parcom together with Opportunity Partners, the investment company of Dutch entrepreneur Robert van der Wallen, with Carlyle reinvesting a minority stake. To finance the acquisition, Hunkemöller issued a €50m super senior revolving credit facility due December 2026 and a €340m bridge term loan due July 2027. An intercreditor agreement dated 24 June 2022, governed by English law with the exclusive jurisdiction of the English courts, set the rules between the financiers: the Security Agent (TMF) holds the security, enforces only on the instruction of an Instructing Group, and on enforcement of pledged shares must obtain a fairness opinion.
On 31 October 2022, Hunkemöller issued €272.5m of 9% senior secured notes due November 2027 to repay part of the bridge (€67.5m remained outstanding) under an indenture governed by New York law, with BNY Mellon Corporate Trustee Services as trustee. The notes existed as a single global note registered to a BNY Mellon depositary and traded through Euroclear and Clearstream, the standard custody structure the English court later dissected at length. Of the issuance, the funds now suing took €84.325m, Redwood took €186.075m, and other investors took the remaining €2.1m.
The decline
2023 proved a challenging operating year for Hunkemöller. High inflation and falling disposable income across the Benelux and German markets that carry most of its stores depressed demand, and costs — wages, energy, rents — kept climbing, while the 2022 refinancing left the company paying market rates on its facilities and 9% on its notes. Sales for the year to January 2024 fell 8% to €542.3m, EBITDA fell by a third to €42.8m, and the company booked a net loss of €141.8m including a €109m goodwill write-off. It closed 45 stores over the year, and another 45 closures were already announced. S&P cut the rating to CCC+ in November 2023 and Moody's followed.
The claimant funds — the Cheyne, Contrarian and Man vehicles — say they repeatedly offered the company additional financing during this period, and that unlike Redwood they asked for no special treatment for it. That offer is part of their narrative in the Dutch filing; the company's answer is that it faced an acute liquidity crisis and had to restructure for all stakeholders.
The sponsor question hung over all of it. Carlyle had taken most of its money off the table in March 2022, keeping only a minority stake, and the new owners were financial investors without a record of writing equity cheques into a struggling retailer. As the losses mounted it became clear that neither would put fresh capital behind the business, and its future shifted from the boardroom to the creditor base.
The three-step uptier
The transaction in question was executed in three moves in the spring of 2024, each resting on a different legal order: a New York indenture, a Luxembourg pledge, an English intercreditor agreement.
The first step amended the indenture. On 12 April 2024 the company executed a second supplemental indenture, which deleted section 4.18 of the indenture — the covenant barring the company from paying any consideration to a holder as an inducement to a consent, waiver or amendment unless the same consideration was offered to all holders. It took only majority consent, and Redwood, then holding 68% of the notes, was that majority. On 10 June 2024 the company executed a third supplemental indenture, issued a new global note for €186,075,000 held by Redwood alone, in exchange for Redwood cancelling its existing notes and cutting the face of the original global note to €86,425,000, of which 97.6% belonged to the claimant group, and executed a fourth supplemental indenture giving the new notes priority over the old. Redwood, holding €186.075m of the €272.5m issue, consented to amendments it itself proposed.
The second step funded Redwood ahead of everyone else. On 7 June 2024 Redwood entered into a €50m super senior term loan of new money, ranking ahead of the entire stack. Two changes made that ranking possible. The loan was contracted to sit above the notes and the bridge from the outset. And the fourth supplemental indenture rewrote section 6.10 of the indenture — the waterfall that orders payments once a default has occurred — so that the notes Redwood now held would be paid ahead of the notes of anyone who had not provided new money. Section 6.10 was not one of the indenture's sacred rights, the provisions that take the consent of 90% of affected holders to amend, so a simple majority was enough, and Redwood was that majority; the funds concede the indenture required no supermajority here.
The third step dismantled the structure. On 20 February 2025 two Luxembourg companies, Hunkemöller Holding Sarl and HKM Holding Sarl, were inserted above the group; on 21 February Redwood committed €25m of unsecured interim facilities due May 2025, bought up the remaining drawdown commitments of the RCF and bridge lenders, and agreed a further €14m under the super senior loan. The same day the Security Agent engaged Grant Thornton to value the group. On 11 March 2025 a Luxembourg share pledge was granted over the new holding chain.
After those steps the stack looked like this:
Three instruments were Redwood's alone: the super senior term loan, which stood at €66.4m after the February accordion; the bridge facility, whose remaining drawdown commitments Redwood had bought up; and the €25m of interim facilities, which the table does not show. Of the rest it held €186.1m of the notes — 68% — and €17m of the drawn revolving facility. The €86.4m stub, 97.6% of it, belonged to the claimant group.
The defaults that armed the enforcement came quickly: a missed interest payment under the bridge on 28 February 2025, a missed interest payment under the super senior loan on 10 March 2025, recognised as an Event of Default under the intercreditor agreement on 12 March 2025. On 21 March 2025 the Security Agent, instructed by Redwood — which held 84.5% of the super senior liabilities and 74.5% of the senior secured liabilities, above the 66⅔% and 50% thresholds the intercreditor agreement requires — enforced the pledge. The shares of HKM Holding went to a Redwood vehicle for €1, and all of the super senior and senior secured liabilities, including the claimants' notes, were transferred to it for €86.7m in cash. On 24 March 2025 the remaining original notes were cancelled. Redwood owned the company; the other funds now held claims against a Redwood entity.
The valuation that authorised all of it came from Grant Thornton, engaged on 21 February and delivering its fairness opinion on the enforcement day itself. Its report valued the group on a going-concern basis at €141.7m to €155.3m of enterprise value, then applied a 40% distressed-sale discount and other adjustments to reach €82.6m to €90.7m, from which it deducted the €27.6m of interim facilities — outside the intercreditor agreement, and sitting in a structurally senior subsidiary — to value the transferred debt at €58.9m. Redwood paid €86.7m, roughly 47% above that number, and Grant Thornton opined the proceeds were “fair from a financial point of view” and “the best price reasonably obtainable”. Under the intercreditor agreement that opinion is conclusive evidence that the enforcement objective — maximising the recovery of the super senior, senior secured and pari passu creditors — has been met.
The claimants read the same event differently. On their pleaded case the total consideration was €87.6m; the Instructing Group allocated €1.7m of it to the senior secured creditors despite their being, on the defendants' own case, out of the money; and of that, €1.357m went to the noteholders — the “Notes Agreed Amount” — which they call de minimis consideration for the extinguishment of €84.3m of debt. The defendants answer that the notes were worth nothing at all, so even the small allocation overpaid them.
The court battle
New York
The New York complaint attacks each step on the indenture: section 4.18, the covenant barring any payment or consideration to a holder for consenting to an amendment unless the same consideration is offered to all holders (the “Payments for Consent” clause, deleted in the process); sections 2.01(b) and 2.01(c), which require additional notes to be substantially identical to the original issue and issued with holders' consent; section 3.02, which requires redemptions to be pro rata; and the “sacred rights” in sections 9.02(c) and 9.02(h), which require the consent of 90% of holders to reduce principal or release all or substantially all of the security. The original complaint also pleaded the uptier as an intentional and constructive fraudulent transfer under New York's Debtor and Creditor Law §§273, 274 and 279 and, in the alternative, under Dutch Civil Code Articles 3:40(1) and 3:45, and pleaded that the trustee was complicit in the breach.
The funds cite S&P's post-exchange call, labelling the June 2024 exchange distressed, cutting the company to “SD” for selective default and withdrawing its ratings at the company's request, and Moody's July 2024 cut of the notes from Caa1 to Ca, as evidence the subordinated notes were left effectively without security. A further strand goes to authority: the registered holder of the notes was the BNY Mellon depositary, and — the funds argue — Redwood never obtained its authorisation to consent, pointing out that Euroclear’s operating rules authorise beneficial owners to bring proceedings but contain no standing authorisation to consent on the depositary’s behalf.
The ad hoc group sued first, filing a complaint in the Commercial Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York, County of New York, on 26 November 2024 against the company, Redwood Capital and BNY Mellon. An amended complaint of 5 March 2025 substituted the two Redwood fund vehicles, Redwood Master Fund Ltd and Redwood Drawdown Master Fund III LP, as defendants, and two days before that the funds had served the company an extrajudicial annulment notice under Article 3:45 of the Dutch Civil Code. The defendants moved to dismiss on 31 March 2025, days after the enforcement; on 17 July 2025 the court dismissed the claims against the Redwood holders and BNY Mellon and pared the claims against the company: the trustee's motion was granted to the extent of Count VIII, the breach-of-contract claim against BNY Mellon; the fraudulent transfer counts (IV-VII, pleaded under New York's Debtor and Creditor Law and, in the alternative, Dutch law), the implied-covenant count (III) and the declaratory judgment count (I) fell as to the company; and Count II, the breach-of-contract claim against Hunkemöller International, survived in part — the court dismissed the breaches pleaded under indenture sections 3.02, 9.02(c) and 9.02(h) but let the claim proceed on breaches of sections 2.01, 9.02 (otherwise), 4.18, 2.07 and 2.11.
The second amended complaint of 19 August 2025 pressed a single breach-of-contract count against the company alone, and the third amended complaint of 20 March 2026 added the first English claimant as a plaintiff. The defendants' answer raises a procedural weapon the complaint does not mention: under section 6.06 of the indenture, the trustee notified the claimants on 21 November 2024 that it had received letters dated 5 September and 19 November 2024 from a majority of noteholders waiving the alleged defaults and directing it not to pursue litigation over the uptier — a direction the defendants say bars the claimants' challenge outright. The New York court directed that the section 6.06 issues be resolved by summary judgment or trial. Discovery is complete: the parties produced some 20,000 documents and deposed 19 witnesses, and a summary judgment motion is planned. The funds' US counsel, Duane Loft of Pallas, expects a bench trial in the first quarter of 2027 and a first-instance judgment no earlier than the summer or early fall of 2027, possibly into early 2028, with an appeal as of right adding twelve to eighteen months.
The defendants rest on Mitel, the First Department's ruling of 31 December 2024, which dismissed a nearly identical uptiering attack: where an indenture permits amendments by majority consent, the implied covenant adds nothing, and no sacred right reaches a transaction with only an “effective or functional” effect. Redwood's papers call the €50m financing a counter badge of fraud, and argue the April and June amendments sit months apart, too far to collapse into one transaction; the funds answer that the same parties pursued the same purpose in both, that the fourth supplemental indenture's own text ties the payment priority to the financing, and that removing the payments-for-consent clause was itself the payment for Redwood's consent.
The consent fight runs through UMB Bank v Bristol-Myers Squibb, a September 2024 Southern District ruling that instructions from beneficial owners cannot stand in for the registered holder's authorisation: the funds say every Redwood consent, waiver and counter-direction fails on that footing, while the defendants read the indenture as letting the company and trustee give effect to written certifications from Euroclear and Clearstream, and letting the trustee rely conclusively on the certificates and opinions it received. The oppositions also carried a sharper allegation: the executed 2024 global note was signed three days after the authentication order directed authentication on the day of delivery, and the numerals on its signature page sat in a visibly thinner font than the surrounding text, which the funds said suggested alteration; BNY Mellon called that a “ludicrous conspiracy theory” and the court never reached it. On Dutch law the parties filed competing expert affirmations, Professor Verstijlen for the funds and Paul Michael Veder for Redwood, arguing over whether a Dutch court would void the uptier under Article 3:40(1) or unwind it under Article 3:45; the court never got there, dismissing the Dutch-law counts on New York's choice of law.
The funds also ran a separate federal discovery action. On 24 April 2025 the Cheyne fund applied in the Southern District of New York under 28 U.S.C. §1782, the statute permitting discovery in the United States for use in foreign proceedings, against Redwood, supported by a declaration from their Dutch counsel. The matter closed on 30 June 2026, its product folded into the New York record.
Amsterdam
The Cheyne, Contrarian and Man Group vehicles applied to the Amsterdam District Court under the Dutch pre-trial evidence provisions for document inspection and the preliminary examination of the group's directors, in support of a planned damages and nullity action against Shero Holdco BV, the top holding company, and the directors personally. The respondents were Hunkemöller International BV, its immediate parent Shero Midco BV, Shero Holdco BV and three named directors. After an interim decision on 21 August 2025 and a narrowing of the request on 22 September 2025 — the funds withdrew their demands for the Grant Thornton opinion, the pledge deed and the enforcement notification — the court heard the parties on 2 October 2025 and refused the application on 22 January 2026.
The Amsterdam court held the requests premature and speculative: no foreign court has yet held anyone liable for the transactions or voided any of them, the directors' liability under Dutch law requires serious personal blame the funds had not yet articulated, the threshold for the holding company is higher still, and granting the requests would degenerate into a fishing expedition. On the contractual defences the court said nothing. It assumed, without deciding, that the indenture's no-action clause, its bar on recourse against directors and shareholders, and the intercreditor agreement's English forum clause would not by themselves stop a Dutch claim against Holdco and the directors. What closed the door was prematurity alone: until a court somewhere holds someone liable or voids one of the transactions, the funds' theories of director and shareholder liability remain, in the court's words, speculation. The Dutch door is closed for now; the ruling leaves the funds free to return once the foreign courts have spoken.
London
The funds issued their English claim form on 10 October 2025 against TMF Trustee Limited and Hunkemöller International BV, serving particulars a week later. The claim has two limbs. The first says the enforcement was invalid because there was no valid Instructing Group: the up-tiered notes were issued in breach of the indenture, the cancelled notes were no longer participations, and on the funds' arithmetic they themselves held 54.8% of the €153.9m of senior secured participations outstanding at enforcement. The second runs under English law: the majority's power to bind the minority under the intercreditor agreement carries an implied term, in the tradition of the English authorities on majority instructions to a security agent, that it be exercised bona fide in the interests of the class as a whole, and Redwood's instructions were instead a bargain-hunt — the enforcement delivered the company to Redwood at a fraction of what the secured package was worth. The Security Agent served its defence and counterclaim on 12 December 2025, resting on the trustee's direction, Grant Thornton's opinion and the valuation; the company amended its defence on 6 July 2026 and the claimants replied on 13 July.
The defendants applied on 2 June 2026 for a stay of the English claim until the New York court had ruled; the English court heard the application at the first case management conference on 27 July 2026 and, on 6 August 2026, granted it. The reasoning is a case study in parallel litigation: there is a single test, the interests of justice; the risk of inconsistent judgments — and of an “ugly rush” to judgment in England while New York grinds on — is a strong reason to stay; the two English claims cannot be hived off from the New York question, because the abuse-of-power claim turns on the same valuation and validity issues; and although the claimants are not parties to the intercreditor agreement — beneficial owners of a global note hold no contractual rights — their English nexus argument was accepted but not decisive. New York law belongs in New York, and New York is far further advanced. The stay runs until the New York first-instance judgment; the defendants may seek to extend it over any appeal, and the claimants may apply to lift it on a material change of circumstances — the court noted that one claimant fund, Cheyne European Strategic Value Credit Fund II, reaches its end of life on 30 June 2027.
What we're watching from here
Hunkemöller trades on under Redwood's ownership. The notes are cancelled; the claimants' €84.3m exists only as litigation. The milestones, in order:
- A summary judgment motion in New York, planned now that discovery is complete. If it does not resolve the case, a bench trial is expected in the first quarter of 2027.
- A first-instance New York judgment no earlier than the summer or early fall of 2027, possibly into early 2028.
- An appeal as of right, adding twelve to eighteen months.
- The English claim, stayed until the New York first-instance judgment; the defendants may seek to extend the stay over any appeal, and the claimants may apply to lift it on a material change of circumstances. The Cheyne European Strategic Value Credit Fund II end-of-life on 30 June 2027 sits inside that window and may force decisions before the New York case is over.
- Amsterdam, where the door reopens only once the foreign courts have spoken.
Counsel
New York: Pallas Partners for the claimant funds; Kobre & Kim for the company and the Redwood parties. Amsterdam: Gijs Berkhout for the funds; Sander Jansen for the Dutch defendants. London: Lord Wolfson KC and Abra Bompas (Pallas) for the claimants; David Allison KC and Ryan Perkins (Kobre & Kim) for the defendants. BNY Mellon: Morgan Lewis.
Sources
- England and Wales High Court (Chancery Division), judgment of 6 August 2026, Cheyne European Special Situations Fund Investments SCA & Ors v TMF Trustee Limited & Anor — caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewhc/ch/2026/2091
- Rechtbank Amsterdam, 22 January 2026, case C/13/770181 / HA RK 25-179, ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2026:346 — rechtspraak.nl
- In re: Application of Cheyne European Strategic Value Credit RAIF for an order pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §1782, No. 1:25-mc-00180 (S.D.N.Y., filed 24 April 2025, terminated 30 June 2026) — RECAP docket, https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/69936251/cheyne-european-strategic-value-credit-raif-cheyne-european-special/
- Complaints, Cheyne European Strategic Value Credit Raif & Ors v Hunkemöller International B.V. & Ors, Supreme Court of the State of New York, Index No. 659297/2024: all versions read directly on the NYSCEF docket, iapps.courts.state.ny.us (complaint of 26 November 2024, NYSCEF Doc 2; amended complaint of 5 March 2025, Doc 47; second amended complaint of 19 August 2025, Doc 206; third amended complaint of 20 March 2026, Docs 494 and 499); decision + order on Motions 001-003 of 17 July 2025, Docs 184-186 (identical copies of the same short-form order), and certified transcripts of the 16 and 17 July 2025 argument, Docs 195 and 196, read directly on the docket; the motions' supporting briefs (Docs 67, 79 and 93), plaintiffs' oppositions (Docs 141-143) and defendants' replies (Docs 155, 156, 163) with Redwood's Dutch-law reply affirmation (Doc 157) as listed in the decision's document index)
- Indenture dated 31 October 2022 and second, third and fourth supplemental indentures of 12 April and 10 June 2024, as quoted in the judgment of 6 August 2026
- Intercreditor Agreement dated 24 June 2022 (including Schedule 5, Security Enforcement Principles), as quoted in the judgment of 6 August 2026
- Grant Thornton (UK) LLP, Financial Advisor's Opinion and Valuation Report, 21 March 2025, as pleaded in the Security Agent's Defence and quoted in the judgment of 6 August 2026
- Witness statements of Zachary Rosenbaum (1 June 2026), Duane Loft (16 June 2026) and Fiona Huntriss (17 June 2026), quoted in the judgment of 6 August 2026
- Reuters, “Maxeda to sell lingerie chain Hunkemoeller to PAI”, 23 November 2010
- Reuters, “Carlyle to buy Dutch lingerie retailer Hunkemöller: source”, 11 December 2015
- Private Equity Wire / Institutional Investor, “PAI completes Hunkemoller acquisition”, 3 February 2011
- Carlyle Group / Hunkemöller, press release, “Hunkemöller to be sold to leading Dutch investors, including Parcom and Opportunity Partners, with Carlyle reinvesting for a minority stake”, 23 March 2022
- DutchNews.nl, “Another 45 shops close as Hunkemöller profits sag”, 4 July 2024
- RetailDetail, “Hunkemöller needs push-up after disappointing year”, 1 July 2024
- RTL Nieuws, “Nieuwe eigenaar haalt bezem door Hunkemöller: 90 winkels dicht”, 1 July 2024
- RetailDetail, Hunkemöller FY2023 results coverage, 2024
- S&P Global Ratings downgrade announcements, November 2023; Moody's Ratings, 2023–24
- Bloomberg, “Cheyne, Man and Contrarian sue over Hunkemöller uptiering”, 17 October 2025
- Global Restructuring Review, “Hunkemöller claimants survive partial dismissal in New York”, 20 March 2026
- K&L Gates, client note on the English stay, August 2026
- FashionNetwork / WWD, Carlyle–PAI sale coverage, December 2015